• Home
  • About
    • Beliefs
    • Non-Denominational
    • Why Christianity?
  • Sermons
  • Leadership
  • Contact
  • Directions
  • C3 Cafe
Give

Scandalous Scripture: The Bible We Don't Read in Church

Part 17 - Tell Me What I Want to Hear

What happens when 400 prophets tell a king exactly what he wants to hear—but one prophet tells him the truth? In Part 17 of Scandalous Scripture, Pastor Gene Simco explores one of the Bible's most surprising accounts: King Ahab, the prophet Micaiah, and the lying spirit described in 1 Kings 22. Why would God authorize a lying spirit? Why did Ahab reject the truth even after being warned? And how does this ancient account expose something Christians still struggle with today? Confirmation bias. Sometimes we approach Scripture not to discover what God says, but to find someone who agrees with what we already believe. We'll examine false teachers, spiritual deception, Scripture taken out of context, and the difference between genuine biblical conviction and religious entertainment. Most importantly, we'll discover how to recognize trustworthy teaching, examine our own motives, and remain willing to be corrected by God's Word. Don't just test the teacher. Test why you want to believe the teacher. Join us at C3 Church Naples, where we believe Scripture should shape our lives—not simply affirm our preferences.

Video can’t be displayed

Reader's Version

  • Scandalous Scripture — Part 17

  • Tell Me What I Want to Hear

  • Sermon by Gene Simco

  • Reader’s Version


  • You Can Really Take a Beating!

  • Last week was pretty heavy. We talked about church attendance and spiritual discipline, and it was a little like going to the gym. I went into full coach mode—not full Paul mode. As you know, no names were mentioned last week, but apparently the message still landed pretty hard. I think I saw someone come into church today wearing a hockey uniform. Someone even told me they were wearing a cup, which was entirely too much information. Besides, that's not how this works!

  • I've mentioned before that I spent years in the MMA industry, and one of the things I learned was that taking a hit is a huge part of the process. But what matters isn't simply whether you can take a hit. It's whether you recover, learn something from it, and keep coming back. And I have to say, you guys can really take a beating! You remind me of some of those indestructible things from my childhood that they just don't make anymore. Remember Weebles? Or that Tupperware from the 1980s? Actually, looking around my kitchen, I think some of that Tupperware is still there. Then there were the punching bags at the gym. But perhaps the best comparison would be those old telephones. Do you remember how durable those things were?

  • I don't think we even manufacture materials like that anymore. It's almost as though we ran out of the stuff after the Cold War. Those telephones were made of plastic, but it was some kind of World War II-era, military-grade plastic. The only modern material I can think of that might compare is vibranium! We actually had one of those phones at my old MMA gym, and that thing took a serious beating. Occasionally, I'd receive a phone call that didn't go particularly well. I'd hang up, pick up the receiver again, and slam it down several more times for good measure. It was my way of killing the messenger without actually killing anybody.

  • Thinking about that old telephone, I wondered whether perhaps we needed one here at the church. After all, I went pretty hard on you last Sunday, and not only did you come back, but you didn't kill the messenger! So I thought we'd take a little break this morning and discuss something lighter, something encouraging, something that really brings everybody together. Let's talk about tithing!

  • I'm kidding, of course, although some of you looked like you were about to tap out before the first round! But there's an important distinction behind all the humor. We don't gather as a church to get beaten up; we gather to be built up. Sometimes building strength involves resistance, and sometimes spiritual growth involves correction. That was part of what we learned last week through the account of Jeroboam.


  • From Jeroboam to the Danger of Deception

  • Last week, we examined how Jeroboam took the worship of God and rearranged it around the interests of his earthly kingdom. Instead of submitting his kingdom to God, he expected God to fit into the kingdom he was building. We also encountered that strange account in 1 Kings 13 involving a man of God who had received specific instructions from the Lord. He successfully resisted a king who wanted him to disobey those instructions, but then another prophet came along claiming that God had given him a different message. The man of God accepted that claim and was persuaded to do precisely what God had forbidden.

  • Think about the contrast. This man resisted the pressure of a king, but he fell for a religious voice. He wouldn't compromise when the instruction came from political authority, yet he accepted a contradictory message when someone presented it as a revelation from God.

  • Today, we're going to encounter something even more disturbing. What happens when approximately four hundred prophets tell a king exactly what he wants to hear, while one prophet delivers an entirely different message? And what happens when the king already knows which message he prefers? Even more troubling, what do we do with a passage in which Scripture actually describes God authorizing a lying spirit?

  • Now we're getting into some truly scandalous Scripture! But underneath this extraordinary account is a question that reaches far beyond the ancient kings of Israel. Are we coming to God's Word to discover what He says, or are we looking for someone who will tell us what we already want to hear?


  • The Fast-Forward Button: From Jeroboam to Ahab

  • We're going to move through several chapters pretty quickly, not because they're unimportant, but because our main event is waiting for us in 1 Kings 22. For now, we're going to make our way through chapters 14 through 20. And remember, this is the Bible we don't usually read. There are some extraordinary accounts tucked away in these chapters that most Christians rarely hear about.

  • Remember that fast-forward button my AI was talking about last week? Well, here it comes!

  • A Slew of Scandals: Assassinations, Civil War, and a Seven-Day King

  • In 1 Kings 14–16, we witness the northern kingdom of Israel continuing its downward spiral. Following Jeroboam, its first king after the division of the kingdom, Israel passes through a succession of unstable dynasties, conspiracies, assassinations, and continued idolatry. Remember that we're now dealing with two separate kingdoms: Israel in the north and Judah in the south. Keeping that distinction in mind becomes increasingly important as we follow their different kings.

  • By the time we reach 1 Kings 16, the scandals are coming so quickly that it's difficult to keep track of who's killing whom. We encounter Elah, the son of Baasha, who becomes king of Israel and is assassinated while drinking. His murderer is Zimri, an army officer who not only kills the king but proceeds to wipe out Baasha's entire dynasty, fulfilling the judgment previously announced through the prophet Jehu.

  • Zimri's reward for all that bloodshed is a remarkably short reign. He becomes king for precisely seven days! That's right, seven days. Barely enough time to get comfortable on the throne before everything falls apart.

  • Meanwhile, the army proclaims its commander, Omri, king of Israel. Omri marches against Zimri and besieges Tirzah, the capital. Realizing that his reign is finished, Zimri retreats into the royal palace, sets it on fire, and dies inside. It's a dramatic ending to one of the shortest reigns in Israel's history.

  • But even that doesn't settle the question of who will rule. Israel divides into rival factions, with some supporting Omri and others supporting Tibni, the son of Ginath. Another civil conflict follows, Tibni eventually dies, and Omri secures the throne. It's almost impossible to imagine a more chaotic political situation, but this is the history of Israel's northern kingdom during this period.

  • Omri and the Birth of Samaria

  • Omri initially rules from Tirzah, but he eventually decides to establish a new capital. According to 1 Kings 16:24, he purchases a hill from a man named Shemer for two talents of silver. He builds a fortified city on that hill and names it Samaria after its former owner.

  • And just like that, Samaria is born!

  • Now, this is an important detail that will help us understand quite a bit of the New Testament. At this point in biblical history, Samaria is the new capital of the northern kingdom of Israel, while Judah remains the southern kingdom. The city eventually gives its name to the surrounding region, and centuries later, we encounter the Samaritans in the Gospels.

  • The development of the Samaritan people and their religious identity involves a much longer history, including the Assyrian conquest of the northern kingdom in 722 BC, competing claims of Israelite ancestry, and a religious division centered on Jerusalem and Mount Gerizim. We shouldn't confuse the founding of Omri's capital with the much later emergence of that entire dispute. Nevertheless, this is an important starting point for understanding the geography and history behind the hostility between Jews and Samaritans in Jesus' day.

  • Think about how significant that becomes when we reach the New Testament. Jesus tells the parable of the Good Samaritan in Luke 10, deliberately making a Samaritan the unexpected example of neighborly love. In John 4, He speaks with a Samaritan woman at a well, crossing longstanding social and religious boundaries. And in Acts 8, Philip brings the good news of Christ to Samaria, where people receive the message with great joy.

  • Those accounts become even more meaningful when we understand the history behind them. A city that began as the capital of a deeply troubled kingdom eventually becomes part of the setting for some of the New Testament's most remarkable lessons about prejudice, reconciliation, and the expanding reach of the gospel.

  • But for our purposes today, the most important development is what happens next. Omri dies, and his son Ahab takes the throne. And that's when things become even more scandalous.

  • Ahab and Jezebel: Making Jeroboam Look Like the Warm-Up Act

  • Ahab marries Jezebel, the daughter of Ethbaal, king of the Sidonians. Through this marriage, the worship of Baal becomes deeply entrenched in Israel's royal establishment. Ahab builds a temple and altar for Baal in Samaria and makes an Asherah pole, a cultic object associated with the worship of the Canaanite goddess Asherah.

  • The biblical narrator describes Ahab as doing even more evil than the kings who preceded him. That's quite an accomplishment, considering the history we've just reviewed!

  • Think about the progression. Jeroboam established an alternative worship system involving two golden calves, trying to protect his political kingdom by rearranging Israel's worship. But Ahab takes the northern kingdom even further into the worship of Baal. By the time we get to Ahab, Jeroboam is starting to look like the warm-up act!

  • And this brings us to one of the most famous prophets in the Old Testament: Elijah.

  • Elijah: Miracles, Mount Carmel, and the God Who Answers by Fire

  • In 1 Kings 17–19, we encounter some of the most familiar and extraordinary events in Elijah's ministry. We're not going to spend much time on them today, but we certainly don't want to overlook their place in the story.

  • Elijah announces a drought over Israel. During that drought, God provides for him through ravens that bring him food. Later, God miraculously sustains a widow and her son through a supply of flour and oil that doesn't run out. When the widow's son dies, Elijah prays, and God restores the boy's life.

  • Then comes the famous confrontation on Mount Carmel, where Elijah challenges the prophets of Baal. After they fail to obtain an answer from their god, Elijah prepares his sacrifice, drenches it with water, and calls upon the LORD. God answers with fire from heaven, consuming the offering, the wood, the stones, the dust, and even the water in the trench.

  • Following that confrontation, rain finally returns to Israel. And as though we needed one more extraordinary event, Elijah receives supernatural strength and runs ahead of Ahab's chariot toward Jezreel.

  • That's an incredible collection of miracles, and many of you already know the account of the fire coming down from heaven. We're not ignoring these stories; we're placing today's passage on the historical timeline.

  • There's also an important distinction to make here. The 450 prophets of Baal who appear at Mount Carmel in 1 Kings 18 should not automatically be identified with the approximately 400 court prophets we'll encounter in chapter 22. The two accounts involve different circumstances, and Scripture doesn't establish that these are the same people.

  • Elijah's ministry also includes Jezebel threatening his life and his subsequent flight, during which God continues to deal with him. But our focus is on Ahab, so we're going to keep moving.

  • Ahab's Wars: Another Chance to Listen to God

  • In 1 Kings 20, we find Ahab engaged in military conflict with the Arameans. Despite Ahab's wickedness, God gives Israel victories over its enemies. But instead of responding with consistent obedience, Ahab makes a treaty with Ben-hadad, the Aramean king, and allows him to go free.

  • That decision brings yet another prophetic rebuke.

  • This establishes an important pattern in Ahab's life. Ahab is not a man who has never heard from God. He has witnessed divine intervention, received repeated warnings, experienced God's mercy, and been given opportunities to respond. His problem isn't a complete lack of access to the truth.

  • And just before we move into the next chapter, there's another strange little incident that deserves our attention. Remember the lion from last week? Well, apparently, the lions aren't finished making appearances in this series!


  • Another Lion! Another Ignored Instruction

  • In 1 Kings 20:35–36, one of the sons of the prophets receives an instruction from the LORD and tells a fellow man to strike him. The man refuses. It's certainly an unusual request, and perhaps we can understand why someone might hesitate to strike a prophet. But the command came by the word of the LORD, and the refusal has serious consequences.

  • The prophet announces that because the man refused to obey, a lion will kill him. Sure enough, after the man leaves, a lion encounters and kills him.

  • The prophet then approaches another man and gives the same instruction. This time, the man obeys and strikes him, leaving him wounded. The prophet subsequently disguises himself and uses an acted-out encounter to confront Ahab about his decision to release Ben-hadad, a king whom God had designated for judgment.

  • Now think back to 1 Kings 13, where we encountered another man of God, another ignored divine instruction, and another lion bringing judgment. Here we are several chapters later, and we're seeing a remarkably similar pattern.

  • The point isn't that every unusual request someone makes should be treated as a command from God. In these accounts, Scripture explicitly identifies the instructions as coming from the LORD. The warning is that even when God's instructions seem strange or difficult to understand, disobedience still has consequences.

  • And that's becoming a recurring theme throughout these chapters. People receive instructions, warnings, and opportunities to obey, yet repeatedly choose their own way.

  • Ahab has already received extraordinary demonstrations of God's power and repeated prophetic warnings. But before we arrive at the four hundred prophets who will tell him exactly what he wants to hear, there's one more story that reveals a great deal about his character.

  • And strangely enough, it all begins with a vegetable garden.


  • Naboth's Vineyard: When the King Doesn't Get His Way

  • A Vegetable Garden Worth Killing For

  • In 1 Kings 21, we encounter another account that tells us a great deal about Ahab's character, and it all begins with a vegetable garden. Ahab notices a vineyard belonging to a man named Naboth. The property is located near the king's palace, and Ahab thinks it would make a convenient place to grow vegetables. So he approaches Naboth and offers to purchase the land or exchange it for another vineyard.

  • But Naboth refuses. The vineyard is his ancestral inheritance, land that has been passed down through his family. This is more than a simple real-estate disagreement. Under Israel's covenant law, ancestral land carried a significance that went well beyond its monetary value. Naboth isn't merely being difficult or refusing to negotiate a reasonable price. He's seeking to honor the inheritance God had established for his family.

  • Ahab, however, doesn't like the answer. And what does this powerful king of Israel do when someone tells him no? He goes home, lies down on his bed, turns his face toward the wall, and refuses to eat! Here's the king of an entire nation, sulking in his bedroom because somebody won't sell him a vegetable garden.

  • Then Jezebel intervenes. When she discovers why Ahab is so upset, she essentially tells him to get up and start acting like a king. If he wants the vineyard, she'll take care of it. But her solution reveals just how deeply corruption has taken hold of Israel's royal household.

  • Jezebel writes letters using Ahab's royal authority and sends instructions to the leaders of Naboth's city. She orders them to proclaim a public fast, place Naboth in a prominent position before the people, and arrange for two false witnesses to accuse him of cursing God and the king. The accusation is a capital offense, and the proceedings end with Naboth being executed. With Naboth dead, Ahab takes possession of the vineyard he wanted.

  • When Religion Becomes an Instrument of Evil

  • Notice what Jezebel has done. She hasn't simply ordered someone to murder Naboth in secret. Instead, she has used the appearance of religious seriousness and legal procedure to arrange an innocent man's death. The public fast makes the occasion appear spiritually significant. The witnesses create the appearance of legitimate testimony, and the accusation of blasphemy makes the execution seem like an act of faithfulness to God.

  • Everything has been arranged to make a terrible injustice look righteous.

  • This is an important distinction. Religious activity isn't automatically evidence that something is pleasing to God. Religious language, ceremonies, public declarations, and even the appearance of obedience to biblical law can be manipulated to accomplish something radically opposed to God's instructions.

  • And that should sound familiar after what we learned about Jeroboam. He rearranged Israel's worship to protect his political interests, creating an alternative religious system that served his kingdom rather than submitting to God's commands. Now Jezebel is using the structures and language of religion to accomplish the desires of Ahab. In both cases, something that appears religious is being used to justify something God has not approved.

  • The fact that an action is wrapped in religious language doesn't make it righteous. Sometimes religion becomes the very instrument through which people attempt to accomplish evil.

  • The Unexpected Twist: Ahab Humbles Himself

  • But here's where the story takes an unexpected turn. After Naboth's murder, God sends Elijah to confront Ahab. Elijah announces judgment against the king and his household, exposing the wickedness that has taken place and declaring the consequences that will follow.

  • Considering everything we've learned about Ahab, we might expect him to respond with more arrogance, anger, or defiance. But 1 Kings 21 records something surprising: Ahab humbles himself before God. He tears his clothing, puts on sackcloth, fasts, and conducts himself humbly.

  • And God acknowledges it!

  • In 1 Kings 21:27–29, the LORD tells Elijah that because Ahab has humbled himself, the announced destruction of his dynasty will be postponed until after Ahab's lifetime. Think about that for a moment. Even with a king like Ahab, after all the idolatry, disobedience, injustice, and repeated warnings, the biblical narrative demonstrates that God responds to humility.

  • That's something we shouldn't overlook. Ahab's history is filled with wickedness, but when he humbles himself, God takes notice. It doesn't mean that everything Ahab has done is suddenly erased, and it certainly doesn't mean that all the consequences of his actions have been removed. The judgment against his dynasty is postponed, not canceled, and Ahab himself still has to face the consequences of his continuing decisions.

  • But the account reminds us that even in the midst of these extraordinary stories of judgment, we see God's willingness to respond when someone humbles himself before Him.

  • And our story isn't over.

  • We've now seen Ahab's character. We've watched him reject an answer he didn't like, and we've seen how religious authority can be manipulated to accomplish what someone wants. We've also seen God intervene repeatedly in his life, offering warnings and opportunities to respond.

  • Now we're going to see what happens when this same king wants a particular answer from God—and surrounds himself with people who are more than willing to give it to him.


  • Four Hundred Prophets and One Unwelcome Voice

  • Asking God to Bless a Decision We've Already Made

  • Three years have now passed without war between Israel and Aram. King Ahab decides that he wants to reclaim Ramoth-gilead, a strategically important city, and approaches Jehoshaphat, the king of Judah, about joining him in battle. Remember that we're dealing with two kingdoms at this point in Israel's history. Sometimes these kings were at war with one another, and at other times they cooperated. In this particular instance, Jehoshaphat expresses his willingness to support Ahab's military campaign.

  • But then Jehoshaphat says something interesting. He suggests that they should first inquire of the LORD.

  • Notice the sequence in 1 Kings 22:4–5. Ahab asks Jehoshaphat, "Will you join me in battle to recover Ramoth-gilead?" Jehoshaphat responds enthusiastically: "Why, of course! You and I are as one. My troops are your troops, and my horses are your horses." But then, after expressing his willingness to join the campaign, Jehoshaphat adds, "But first let's find out what the LORD says."

  • Did you notice what happened? Jehoshaphat has already agreed to help Ahab, and only afterward does he suggest finding out whether God approves of the plan. Now, we shouldn't build an entire doctrine out of that one sequence, but it's certainly worth considering. Have you ever made a decision, committed yourself to it, and then asked God to bless it?

  • Perhaps it was a relationship, a career opportunity, a financial decision, or even a ministry plan. We decide what we want to do, become emotionally or practically invested in the outcome, and then begin asking God for confirmation. But sometimes we're not really asking God what we should do. We're asking Him to approve of what we've already decided to do.

  • That distinction becomes particularly important as the account unfolds, because Ahab is about to demonstrate just how dangerous it can be when someone approaches God with an answer already in mind.

  • Four Hundred Prophets, One Message

  • In 1 Kings 22:6–8, Ahab summons approximately four hundred prophets and asks whether he should go to war against Ramoth-gilead or hold back. Their response is unanimous. They all encourage him to proceed, confidently announcing that the Lord will give the king victory.

  • Imagine the scene. Four hundred prophets gathered before the king, all delivering precisely the same encouraging message. Go to war! Attack Ramoth-gilead! Victory is assured! From Ahab's perspective, everything sounds wonderful. He has assembled an impressive collection of religious voices, and every one of them is telling him exactly what he wants to hear.

  • But Jehoshaphat isn't satisfied. He asks, "Is there not also a prophet of the LORD here? We should ask him the same question."

  • Remember that question, because it tells us something important about what is happening. Despite the apparent agreement among these hundreds of prophets, Jehoshaphat still wants another word from the LORD. He recognizes that an impressive display of religious agreement doesn't necessarily settle the matter.

  • Ahab reluctantly admits that there is another prophet they could consult. His name is Micaiah, the son of Imlah. But Ahab immediately adds a revealing complaint: "There is one more man who could consult the LORD for us, but I hate him. He never prophesies anything but trouble for me!" Jehoshaphat rebukes him for speaking that way and insists that they hear what Micaiah has to say.

  • Now stop and consider what Ahab has just admitted. He doesn't say that Micaiah has repeatedly made false predictions. He doesn't accuse him of being exposed as a fraudulent prophet. His complaint is simply that Micaiah never tells him anything good.

  • In other words, Ahab is evaluating the prophet according to whether he likes the message, not whether the message is true. That's an important distinction, and it's going to become one of the central themes of our study.

  • The scene becomes even more remarkable in verses 10–12. Ahab and Jehoshaphat are seated in their royal robes while the prophets perform before them. One prophet named Zedekiah even fashions a set of iron horns and uses them to act out the victory he's predicting. The production is impressive, the message is unanimous, and the prophets are confident.

  • Think about it. Four hundred prophets, two kings dressed in royal robes, dramatic visual aids, and everybody predicting victory. What a cool worship service!

  • But Jehoshaphat still isn't satisfied.

  • And here's something we need to notice. These prophets are claiming religious authority. At least Zedekiah explicitly invokes the LORD in delivering his prediction. This isn't simply a gathering of people offering their personal opinions about military strategy. They are presenting their message as something that comes from God.

  • But the fact that someone claims to speak for God does not establish that God has actually spoken. An impressive presentation doesn't establish truth. Confidence doesn't establish truth. And the fact that hundreds of people are saying exactly the same thing doesn't establish truth.

  • You'd think a four-hundred-to-one vote would settle the matter, but God doesn't take a vote to determine what's true.

  • So they send for Micaiah.


  • Micaiah: The Prophet Who Refused to Play Along

  • Before Micaiah even enters the room, we discover that the pressure to conform is already underway. According to 1 Kings 22:13–18, the messenger sent to retrieve him offers some friendly advice: "Look, all the prophets are promising victory for the king. Be sure that you agree with them and promise success."

  • Think about what the messenger is asking. Everyone else is predicting victory. They're all in agreement. The king is pleased with what they're saying. So please, just go along with everybody else and deliver a favorable message. Don't complicate things by telling the king something he doesn't want to hear.

  • Micaiah, however, responds, "As surely as the LORD lives, I will say only what the LORD tells me to say." He isn't interested in adjusting his message to match the expectations of the court. Whatever God has revealed is what Micaiah intends to deliver, regardless of how unpopular it might be.

  • But when Micaiah finally appears before Ahab, the story takes an unexpectedly humorous turn.

  • Ahab asks him the same question he asked the other prophets: Should they attack Ramoth-gilead, or should they hold back? Micaiah initially gives him exactly the answer he wants, telling him to go ahead and expect victory. But Micaiah says it sarcastically!

  • And apparently, Ahab knows him well enough to recognize the sarcasm immediately. Instead of celebrating the favorable prediction, he becomes upset and demands that Micaiah tell him the truth.

  • You have to appreciate the irony. Ahab finally gets Micaiah to say something encouraging, and now he's angry because the prophet doesn't mean it! There's just no satisfying this guy.

  • Once Ahab demands a sincere answer, Micaiah tells him what he actually saw. In a vision, he witnessed Israel scattered across the mountains like sheep without a shepherd. The LORD declared that their master had been killed and that the people should return home in peace.

  • The implication is unmistakable. Israel is going to lose its king.

  • Now consider Ahab's response. Does he ask Micaiah for more information? Does he reconsider his military plans? Does he express concern about the possibility that God is warning him against going to war?

  • Not at all. Instead, he turns to Jehoshaphat and essentially says, "See! I told you this guy never says anything good about me!"

  • He doesn't seriously engage with the warning. He's annoyed with the messenger.

  • What's particularly remarkable is that Ahab clearly understands the difference between Micaiah's sarcastic flattery and his genuine prophetic warning. He recognizes that the first answer wasn't sincere, insists on hearing the truth, and then immediately dismisses that truth because he doesn't like what it says.

  • The central problem isn't that Ahab is incapable of recognizing an unfavorable message. It's that he prefers the voices promising him success. His standard isn't, "Is this true?" It's, "Do I like what he says?"

  • And that brings us to the most scandalous part of the entire account.


  • The Lying Spirit: Does God Actually Do That?

  • A Glimpse Into the Heavenly Court

  • Now we're going to read something unusual. And before trying to explain it away or make it fit neatly into our existing theology, I want us to pay attention to what Scripture actually says.

  • In 1 Kings 22:19–23, Micaiah describes a vision of the LORD seated upon His throne, surrounded by the armies of heaven standing on His right and on His left. God asks who will entice Ahab to go into battle at Ramoth-gilead so that he will meet his death. Different suggestions are offered, and eventually a spirit comes forward with a proposal.

  • The spirit volunteers to accomplish the task by inspiring Ahab's prophets to speak lies. God asks how the spirit intends to do this, hears the proposal, and authorizes it. The LORD tells the spirit that it will succeed and instructs it to carry out the plan.

  • Micaiah then brings the vision directly into Ahab's situation, declaring that the LORD has put a lying spirit in the mouths of his prophets and has pronounced disaster against him.

  • Now hold on. Here's a scandal!

  • Did we just read that God authorized a lying spirit?

  • Yes. That's what the passage describes.

  • And if we're going to take Scripture seriously, we need to acknowledge what it says rather than immediately softening the account because it makes us uncomfortable. This is one of those passages that forces us to confront questions about God's sovereignty, divine judgment, deception, and human responsibility.

  • So what are we supposed to do with it?

  • Is a Lying Spirit Actually a Thing?

  • First, we should establish that this isn't simply an unfortunate choice of words by a modern Bible translator. The language of the original text is quite clear.

  • In 1 Kings 22:22, the Hebrew expression is רוּחַ שֶׁקֶר (rûaḥ šeqer), meaning a spirit of falsehood or a lying spirit. The Greek Septuagint likewise uses πνεῦμα ψευδές, describing a false or lying spirit. Both the Hebrew and Greek preserve the same essential idea.

  • So we can't dismiss the difficulty by claiming that the English translation has introduced something that wasn't there. The language is there in the ancient text itself.

  • But we also need to be careful about what the passage doesn't tell us. Scripture doesn't identify this spirit by name. It doesn't explicitly say that the spirit is Satan, and it doesn't provide a detailed explanation of the hierarchy or workings of the spiritual world. We shouldn't invent an elaborate account of what must have been happening behind the scenes and then present our speculation as though Scripture had revealed it.

  • What Micaiah gives us is a heavenly-court vision in which a spirit volunteers to deceive Ahab through the mouths of his prophets. The purpose of the vision is to explain the false prophecies being delivered to Ahab and the divine judgment that is about to fall upon him. We should allow the text to make that point without claiming it answers every question we might have about spiritual beings.

  • Does God Actually Authorize Deception?

  • The next question is even more difficult. Does God actually authorize the deception described in this account?

  • According to the narrative, the answer is yes. The spirit volunteers, God authorizes the proposal, and Micaiah explicitly attributes what is happening to the judgment of the LORD. We shouldn't soften the passage into saying that God had absolutely nothing to do with it. That's simply not what the text says.

  • At the same time, Scripture is equally clear that God Himself is truthful. Titus 1:2 speaks of God as one who does not lie, while Hebrews 6:18 declares that it is impossible for God to lie. Those passages cannot simply be discarded because 1 Kings 22 presents a difficult theological situation.

  • So we need to make an important distinction between God personally speaking falsehood and God exercising judgment through a deceptive agent. The account in 1 Kings portrays the latter. God authorizes the action of the spirit as part of His judgment against Ahab, but the text does not present God Himself as personally uttering a lie.

  • Now, recognizing that distinction doesn't magically resolve every philosophical question about divine sovereignty, human responsibility, and the existence of evil. These questions have occupied theologians for centuries, and we shouldn't pretend that a few sentences can settle every difficulty.

  • But we can begin by acknowledging both truths that Scripture places before us. God is truthful, and this particular biblical account describes Him authorizing deception as part of His judgment.

  • Judicial Deception: When People Persistently Reject the Truth

  • That brings us to the question of why God would do something like this in the first place.

  • I believe the strongest interpretation is that we're witnessing what can be described as judicial deception—deception operating as an instrument of divine judgment upon a king who has repeatedly resisted God's warnings.

  • Consider everything we've already learned about Ahab. He has witnessed divine intervention in Israel's battles. He has received prophetic rebukes and experienced God's mercy. Even after the terrible injustice involving Naboth's vineyard, God acknowledged his humility and postponed the announced destruction of his dynasty. Again and again, Ahab has encountered opportunities to respond to the LORD.

  • Yet here he is, surrounded by hundreds of religious voices promising exactly what he wants.

  • It's not that Ahab has never encountered the truth. He's repeatedly resisted it. And now the very messages that appeal to his desires have become instruments of judgment against him.

  • This has significant parallels elsewhere in Scripture, including the New Testament. In 2 Thessalonians 2:9–12, Paul describes people who refuse to love and accept the truth and consequently become subject to divine judgment involving deception. The passage connects their unwillingness to receive the truth with their vulnerability to falsehood.

  • Romans 1:24–28 provides another related example. Paul repeatedly describes God giving people over to their sinful desires and distorted thinking. Rather than continually restraining their rebellion, God allows them to experience the consequences of the direction they have chosen.

  • And James 1:13 reminds us that God does not tempt people to evil. That's an important theological boundary. We must distinguish God's righteous judicial action from treating Him as though He were morally equivalent to the deceptive spirit carrying out the judgment.

  • These passages are related, but they're not interchangeable. Each has its own context, and we shouldn't force them into a single explanation that ignores their differences. What they do demonstrate is that Scripture sometimes describes divine judgment in terms of people being given over to falsehood or to the consequences of their persistent resistance to God's truth.

  • The Most Remarkable Part: God Reveals the Deception

  • But here's what I find particularly remarkable about the account in 1 Kings 22: God exposes the deception to Ahab before the battle even begins.

  • Think about that for a moment.

  • Micaiah stands before Ahab and explains what is happening. He tells the king that the hundreds of prophets promising victory are speaking falsely. He describes the heavenly-court vision, exposes the lying spirit, and announces that disaster awaits Ahab if he proceeds with the campaign.

  • Ahab isn't left completely unaware of what's happening. He receives a truthful warning about the very deception operating against him.

  • And what does he do?

  • He still goes to war.

  • Ahab had four hundred voices telling him exactly what he wanted to hear and one prophet explaining why those voices couldn't be trusted. And he still chose the four hundred!

  • That changes how we understand the story. We're not simply looking at an innocent man who was deceived without any warning. We're watching a king who preferred the reassuring message even after the deception had been exposed.

  • That's a terrifying picture of what persistent resistance to truth can become. Someone can become so attached to a desired outcome that even a direct warning is dismissed in favor of the message that provides reassurance.

  • And that's why this passage has implications far beyond the life of one ancient king.

  • Of course, we need to establish an important boundary here. This account doesn't give us permission to announce that everyone we disagree with is under the influence of a lying spirit. Nor does it establish that every mistaken belief or inaccurate teaching represents a direct act of divine judgment. The passage describes a particular judgment against Ahab, and we shouldn't extend its details beyond what Scripture actually teaches.

  • Nevertheless, the broader warning is unmistakable. Rejecting truth can make people increasingly vulnerable to the very deception they prefer.

  • And if you're thinking that this seems unlike anything else in the Bible, let's briefly consider two other passages.

  • Saul and Ezekiel: When God's Judgment Confronts Persistent Disobedience

  • Saul and the Harmful Spirit

  • We don't have time to explore every detail of these accounts, because each could easily become a study of its own. But they're important enough to mention, particularly because they demonstrate that the experience of Ahab isn't the only place where Scripture connects divine judgment with troubling spiritual activity.

  • Consider Saul, Israel's first king. In 1 Samuel 15, Saul disobeys God's instructions and is confronted by the prophet Samuel. Although Saul attempts to justify his actions, Samuel makes clear that obedience to God is more important than the religious sacrifices Saul offers in defense of his behavior. Saul's rebellion ultimately results in his rejection as king.

  • Then 1 Samuel 16:14 tells us that the Spirit of the LORD departed from Saul and that a harmful or tormenting spirit from the LORD began troubling him. The Hebrew describes this as רוּחַ רָעָה (rûaḥ rāʿāh), an expression that can refer to a bad, evil, or harmful spirit.

  • Now, we need to distinguish Saul's experience from Ahab's. In Saul's case, the account describes spiritual affliction associated with God's judgment upon a disobedient king. In Ahab's case, the heavenly-court vision specifically describes a lying spirit operating through prophetic messages. These aren't necessarily the same spirit, and the biblical accounts don't describe precisely the same operation.

  • Nor should we take Saul's experience and turn it into a general explanation for mental illness, emotional suffering, or every form of spiritual struggle. That's not what the passage establishes.

  • The connection is that both accounts portray God exercising judgment in the lives of kings who have resisted His instructions, and both challenge us to take the biblical descriptions of divine judgment seriously, even when they raise difficult questions.

  • Ezekiel 14: Seeking God While Holding On to Idols

  • Ezekiel 14 provides an even closer theological parallel to what we've encountered in the account of Ahab.

  • In this chapter, some of Israel's elders come to the prophet Ezekiel seeking a word from the LORD. On the surface, that sounds like exactly what they should be doing. They're approaching a prophet of God, apparently looking for divine guidance.

  • But God exposes something about them that isn't immediately visible. These men have already embraced idols in their hearts.

  • That's a remarkable expression, because the problem isn't merely that they've been participating in outward acts of idolatry. Their loyalties are already divided internally. They've allowed other things to occupy a place in their hearts that belongs to God, and they're now approaching Him for guidance without first confronting those competing allegiances.

  • In Ezekiel 14:3, God asks whether He should even allow Himself to be consulted by people who have embraced idols in this way. He then calls them to repent and turn away from those idols.

  • But the passage becomes even more disturbing in verse 9, where God speaks of His involvement in a prophet being deceived or enticed into delivering a message, followed by judgment upon both the prophet and the person seeking the message.

  • The precise wording of this verse raises some interpretive questions, but the larger context is clear. God is confronting people who seek prophetic guidance while remaining committed to the very things that separate them from Him. The problem isn't merely the message they might receive. The problem is the condition of their hearts when they come asking for it.

  • And that's where the account connects so powerfully with Ahab.

  • We've already seen how someone can make a decision and then seek God's approval afterward. We've seen how a king can surround himself with religious voices that promise the outcome he desires. And now Ezekiel shows us people seeking a word from God while holding on to idols in their hearts.

  • It raises a question that every one of us should seriously consider: Are we seeking God's will, or are we seeking God's endorsement of a will we've already chosen?

  • That's the connection I want us to remember. Sometimes the danger begins long before we select a teacher, listen to a sermon, or seek spiritual advice. It begins when we've already decided what answer we want God to give us.

  • And once we've made that decision, it can become remarkably easy to find someone willing to tell us exactly what we want to hear.


  • Ahab's Disguise: You Cannot Hide From God's Word

  • When the Truth-Teller Gets Punished

  • Now let's finish the story. We've seen Ahab surrounded by four hundred prophets who promised him victory, and we've watched Micaiah reveal that their predictions were part of a divine judgment against the king. Ahab has been warned, the deception has been exposed, and he knows exactly what Micaiah has said. The question now is what he's going to do with that information.

  • In 1 Kings 22:24–28, we discover that the situation becomes even more hostile. Zedekiah, the prophet who had fashioned the iron horns to illustrate Ahab's supposed victory, walks up to Micaiah and slaps him across the face. He demands, "Since when did the Spirit of the LORD leave me to speak to you?"

  • Think about the arrogance behind that question. Zedekiah has presented himself as someone speaking by God's Spirit, and now another prophet has challenged his message. Rather than carefully considering what Micaiah has said, he responds by striking him. His confidence in his own spiritual authority has become an excuse for hostility toward someone who disagrees with him.

  • Micaiah isn't intimidated. He answers, "You will find out soon enough when you are trying to hide in some secret room!" In other words, the day is coming when Zedekiah will discover which prophetic message was true.

  • Ahab then orders Micaiah arrested. He commands that the prophet be taken to Amon, the governor of the city, and to his son Joash, where he is to be imprisoned and given nothing but bread and water until the king returns safely from battle. Apparently, Ahab believes that restricting the prophet's freedom will somehow settle the matter.

  • But Micaiah stands by his warning. He declares, "If you return safely, it will mean that the LORD has not spoken through me!" Then he turns to those standing around and tells them to remember his words.

  • Notice the situation. The prophet who delivers the message everybody wants to hear is celebrated, while the prophet who delivers the warning is slapped, humiliated, and imprisoned. The truth-teller gets punished, but that doesn't make his message false.

  • And that's an important lesson in itself. A person's willingness to speak with confidence doesn't establish that he's speaking for God. Neither does his popularity, his position, or the number of people who agree with him. On the other hand, being rejected or mistreated doesn't automatically establish that someone is speaking the truth, either. The question remains whether the message is actually faithful to what God has said.

  • Micaiah's imprisonment doesn't change the truth of his warning, and Ahab's royal authority doesn't give him the ability to overturn God's word.

  • The King Who Thought He Could Hide

  • Despite everything he's heard, Ahab decides to go to war anyway. But his actions in 1 Kings 22:29–30 reveal something particularly interesting about his thinking. Before the battle, Ahab tells Jehoshaphat to wear his royal robes while he himself enters the fighting disguised as an ordinary soldier.

  • Do you see what's happening here? Ahab is being remarkably deceitful. He wants to participate in the battle, but he doesn't want to look like the king of Israel. Meanwhile, Jehoshaphat, the king of Judah, is going into battle dressed in his royal clothing.

  • And that decision nearly gets Jehoshaphat killed.

  • The Aramean commanders have been instructed to concentrate their attack on the king of Israel. When they see Jehoshaphat wearing his royal robes, they initially mistake him for Ahab and pursue him. Jehoshaphat cries out, and the commanders eventually recognize that he isn't the man they're looking for. He survives the encounter.

  • Ahab, meanwhile, believes his disguise has given him an advantage. But then something happens that nobody on the battlefield appears to have planned.

  • According to 1 Kings 22:34–35, an enemy soldier fires an arrow without specifically aiming at Ahab. The arrow strikes the king between the joints of his armor, finding an opening in precisely the place where the armor fails to protect him. Ahab is wounded, and although he remains in the battle for some time, he eventually dies from the injury.

  • Think about the irony. Ahab has changed his outfit, disguised his identity, and arranged for another king to appear in royal clothing. Unfortunately for Ahab, God didn't need a royal name tag to figure out which one he was!

  • From the soldier's perspective, the shot was apparently random. He wasn't deliberately targeting Ahab. But from the perspective of the biblical narrative, the event fulfills the prophetic warning that Ahab had repeatedly refused to accept.

  • And that's the point. You can disguise yourself from people, but you cannot disguise yourself from God's Word.

  • Ahab could imprison Micaiah, disregard his warning, listen to four hundred more agreeable prophets, and even change his appearance on the battlefield. But none of those things could change what God had already declared.

  • The problem was never that Ahab hadn't been warned. The problem was that he didn't want to listen.


  • Jehoshaphat: Mercy Doesn't Always Mean Approval

  • Now, we might reasonably wonder what happened to Jehoshaphat after all of this. After all, he was the king who agreed to join Ahab in battle, and he was nearly killed because of that decision.

  • The parallel account in 2 Chronicles helps us understand what happened next. In 2 Chronicles 19:1–3, Jehoshaphat returns safely to Jerusalem, but he is confronted by the prophet Jehu, the son of Hanani. Jehu rebukes him for helping Ahab and forming an alliance with someone who had acted wickedly before the LORD.

  • At the same time, the prophet acknowledges the good that can be found in Jehoshaphat. He recognizes that Jehoshaphat has taken steps to remove idolatry from Judah and has committed himself to seeking God.

  • That's an important detail because it reminds us that biblical narratives don't always fit into simple categories of entirely good or entirely bad people. Jehoshaphat has demonstrated genuine devotion to God, yet he has also made a serious mistake by supporting Ahab. God preserves his life, but that doesn't mean God approves of everything that brought him into the battle.

  • God showing someone mercy doesn't necessarily mean He approved of the decision that put them in danger.

  • Sometimes we can make a foolish decision, experience God's protection or mercy, and mistakenly interpret the outcome as evidence that our decision must have been right. But surviving the consequences of a mistake isn't the same thing as receiving divine approval.

  • Jehoshaphat was spared, yet he still needed correction. Ahab received a warning, yet he refused to heed it. Both accounts reinforce the importance of allowing God's Word to evaluate our decisions rather than judging those decisions solely by how things happen to turn out.


  • From an Ancient King to the Modern Church

  • Now let's bring this entire story into our own lives.

  • We've followed Ahab through years of disobedience, repeated prophetic warnings, extraordinary demonstrations of God's power, and even an occasion when God responded to his humility. We've watched him surround himself with hundreds of prophets who promised him the outcome he wanted. We've seen Micaiah challenge their message, reveal the deception, and announce what would happen if the king persisted in his plans.

  • And even after hearing all of that, Ahab chose to believe the reassuring voices instead of responding to the warning. He didn't simply lack information. He had access to the truth but preferred the message that supported what he already wanted to do.

  • So what does an ancient king, four hundred prophets, and a deliberately ignored warning have to do with modern Christians who have a Bible, a phone, and practically unlimited access to religious teachers?

  • Actually, quite a lot.


  • Confirmation Bias: When We Make Scripture Say What We Want

  • Are We Searching for Truth or Confirmation?

  • Let's talk about the Bible and how we read it, because there's a term in psychology that helps explain something we've just witnessed in the life of Ahab. It's called confirmation bias, and it describes our tendency to seek, notice, interpret, and remember information that supports what we already believe while discounting information that challenges it.

  • Now, that psychological term helps us understand a pattern in Ahab's behavior, but the biblical account goes further. Scripture isn't merely describing a cognitive tendency. It's confronting a king who repeatedly resisted God's warnings because he preferred what other voices were telling him.

  • The process is remarkably easy to recognize once we understand how it works. It often begins with a desire, moves into selective listening, develops into religious justification, and eventually produces resistance to correction.

  • We begin with something we want. Perhaps it's a relationship, a particular lifestyle, a financial opportunity, a theological position, or even a political conviction. We already have an outcome in mind, and naturally, we'd like to believe that God agrees with us. So we begin searching for support.

  • We find a Bible verse that seems to affirm what we want. Then we discover a commentator, a pastor, a YouTube video, a podcast, or a social-media teacher who supports our conclusion. Before long, we've collected an impressive number of voices telling us that our position must be correct.

  • But what happens when we encounter Scripture that challenges us? Instead of reconsidering our position, we explain away the passage, dismiss the interpretation, or perhaps even become angry with the person who brought it to our attention. Suddenly, we're behaving a lot like Ahab. The problem isn't necessarily that we haven't encountered the truth. It's that the truth is interfering with something we already want.

  • Sometimes we aren't opening the Bible to discover what God thinks. We're looking for a verse that will help us win an argument with God!

  • Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with having convictions, consulting teachers, or researching a theological position. Everyone approaches Scripture with some prior assumptions, and responsible Bible study often involves comparing different interpretations. The problem begins when our assumptions become immune to correction. When we stop asking what a passage actually means and start asking how we can make it support what we already believe, we're no longer handling Scripture responsibly.

  • And this isn't merely an abstract psychological problem. We can see it happening in the way people use the Bible today.


  • Malachi, Money, and the Cosmic Vending Machine

  • Let's consider a familiar example from Malachi, a passage we've examined before. In Malachi 3, God is confronting His people over their covenant unfaithfulness, including their failure to bring the tithes intended for the Temple storehouse. This isn't a cheerful fundraising presentation. It's a serious prophetic rebuke.

  • God accuses the people of robbing Him and announces that they are under a curse because of their unfaithfulness. That's the setting in which we encounter one of the most frequently quoted passages about giving.

  • Malachi 3:10 instructs the people to bring the full tithe into the storehouse so that there will be food in God's house. The LORD then promises to open the windows of heaven and pour out blessing as they return to faithfulness. And He concludes with the remarkable invitation: "Try it! Put me to the test!"

  • Now watch what happens when confirmation bias enters the picture.

  • Someone wants financial prosperity, so they take that verse and announce that God has promised to make them wealthy if they'll give Him money. The argument becomes wonderfully simple: Give money to God, and God will give you even more money in return. The more you give, the more you'll receive.

  • Suddenly, God has become a cosmic vending machine. Put money in, get more money out!

  • And because that interpretation gives us exactly what we wanted, we're satisfied. We've found our verse, established our formula, and apparently settled the theological question. Why would we need to investigate any further?

  • But here's something I keep encouraging people to do when they study Scripture: Keep reading!

  • Just five verses later, in Malachi 3:15, the prophet records people complaining about the apparent prosperity of the wicked. They observe that arrogant people seem to be blessed, that those who do evil become prosperous, and that those who dare to test God apparently suffer no consequences.

  • Here's an interesting detail from the original Hebrew. The verb used for testing in Malachi 3:10 is בָּחַן (bāḥan), and the same Hebrew verb appears again in verse 15. That repetition deserves our attention because the two passages describe very different situations.

  • In verse 10, God seems to invite Israel to test His faithfulness concerning their covenant obligations. Before treating verse 10 as a straightforward authorization, we should ask whether Malachi is using pointed, ironic rhetoric. In verse 15, the people complain that the wicked test God and apparently escape judgment. The same basic verb appears in both places, but the circumstances, attitudes, and purposes are entirely different.

  • And that's why context matters.

  • We need to remember the force of the rebuke throughout Malachi. God has already confronted His people about their unfaithfulness, their dishonesty, and their failure to honor Him. The entire passage challenges the way they're treating their covenant relationship with the LORD.

  • But the invitation in verse 10 is a specific challenge within that covenant relationship, and most probably rhetorical sarcasm (more below). It isn't a universal invitation for anyone, anywhere, to manipulate God into providing personal wealth. And it certainly doesn't establish a mathematical formula by which every dollar placed into an offering produces a guaranteed financial return.

  • The problem isn't believing that God blesses faithfulness. The problem is taking a statement delivered to Israel in a particular covenant setting and turning it into a financial transaction that serves our personal desires.

  • And that brings us to another fascinating connection. Elsewhere in the Law, God expressly warns His people against putting Him to the test. In Deuteronomy 6:16, Israel is commanded not to test the LORD as the people had done at Massah.


  • Even Satan Can Quote Scripture

  • In Matthew 4:5–7, Satan takes Jesus to Jerusalem and places Him on the highest point of the Temple. Then he challenges Jesus to throw Himself down, attempting to justify the suggestion by quoting Scripture.

  • Yes, Satan quotes the Bible!

  • He appeals to Psalm 91, where God promises angelic protection for those who trust Him. Satan quotes the promise that God will command His angels concerning His people and that they will lift them up so that they will not strike their feet against a stone.

  • Think about what's happening here. Satan isn't inventing a passage of Scripture. He's using words that actually appear in the Bible. He's taking a genuine biblical promise and attempting to turn it into a justification for something God has not instructed Jesus to do.

  • The argument sounds spiritual. It appeals to God's protection, invokes the authority of Scripture, and challenges Jesus to demonstrate His confidence in the Father's promises. But underneath the religious language is a temptation to act presumptuously.

  • And how does Jesus respond?

  • He answers Satan by quoting another passage of Scripture, Deuteronomy 6:16: "You must not test the LORD your God."

  • That's remarkable. Satan quotes Scripture in an attempt to persuade Jesus to test God, and Jesus responds by showing why Satan's application of that Scripture is wrong.

  • Notice that Jesus doesn't deny the truth of Psalm 91. He doesn't suggest that the promise of God's protection was false. Instead, Jesus rejects Satan's application of the passage.

  • The difference is enormously important. A biblical quotation can be accurate while the argument built upon it is completely wrong. Someone can quote a real verse, appeal to a genuine promise, and still use Scripture to encourage something that God has not authorized.

  • And if Satan himself used Scripture out of context to tempt Jesus, we had better take seriously the danger of using Scripture to justify what we already want to believe.

  • Now, Satan's actions in Matthew 4 are deliberate deception, while confirmation bias often involves people genuinely persuading themselves that their preferred interpretation is correct. Those aren't exactly the same thing. But the temptation demonstrates just how dangerous selective use of Scripture can become. If even a genuine biblical promise can be twisted into an argument for disobedience, then merely finding a supporting verse isn't enough to establish that our interpretation is sound.

  • That's why we need to examine the context, consider the larger teaching of Scripture, and remain willing to question our own conclusions.



  • The Contradiction We Cannot Ignore

  • Now, here's where I believe Malachi's rhetoric becomes especially important. In Malachi 2:3, God uses shocking language about smearing manure on the priests' faces. Clearly, this prophet isn't afraid of employing provocative imagery to confront his audience. Then, in Malachi 3:15, we find the wicked described as people who test God and apparently get away with it.

  • So when we encounter God's statement in Malachi 3:10 to put Him to the test, I believe we should seriously consider whether this is another example of confrontational, perhaps even sarcastic, prophetic rhetoric.

  • And here's my strongest reason: Scripture must be interpreted consistently with Scripture.

  • Deuteronomy 6:16 explicitly prohibits testing the LORD. More importantly, Jesus Himself reinforces that prohibition in Matthew 4:7 when Satan uses Scripture to encourage Him to test God.

  • Now, someone might object, "But Malachi 3:10 is the one place where God actually tells His people to test Him!"

  • My response is, Exactly! That's precisely why we should examine how we're interpreting it!

  • If this is the only apparent invitation of its kind, while other passages prohibit testing God—and Jesus Himself reinforces that prohibition—why should we assume this one statement establishes a general exception?

  • The usual counterargument is that God can authorize a specific test while prohibiting presumptuous testing. But that distinction still needs to be demonstrated from Scripture, not merely asserted to resolve the difficulty.

  • Otherwise, we're left with an apparent contradiction that the interpretation itself has created.

  • I believe the surrounding rhetoric of Malachi provides a compelling reason to read this as an ironic challenge within God's rebuke of His unfaithful people, rather than permission to put God to the test whenever we want something from Him.

  • The question isn't whether we can find one verse that appears to support our position. It's whether that interpretation holds together when we keep reading the rest of Scripture.


  • The Danger of Stopping at the Verse We Like

  • Think about the connection between Malachi, the temptation of Jesus, and what we've just witnessed in the life of Ahab.

  • In Malachi, someone can isolate a promise about God's faithfulness and turn it into a guarantee of personal financial prosperity. In Matthew, Satan isolates a promise of divine protection and attempts to turn it into a justification for testing God. And in 1 Kings 22, Ahab surrounds himself with prophetic voices that affirm the decision he already wants to make.

  • In each case, the central issue involves what happens when a message is separated from the larger truth that should govern our understanding of it.

  • And that's exactly what confirmation bias can do to our Bible study. We find the verse that gives us the answer we want, stop reading, and ignore the passages that challenge our interpretation. We may even become so invested in that conclusion that we begin to resent anyone who encourages us to reconsider it.

  • But responsible Bible study requires something more than collecting supporting quotations. We need to be willing to examine the verses before and after, understand the historical circumstances, identify who is speaking and to whom, and consider how the passage fits into the larger argument of Scripture.

  • Most importantly, we must remain willing to be corrected.

  • After all, the problem with Ahab wasn't that he lacked prophets. He had four hundred of them! His problem was that he preferred their message because it supported the outcome he wanted.

  • And we can find ourselves doing something remarkably similar whenever we collect biblical quotations, teachers, and interpretations that affirm our desires while refusing to engage seriously with anything that challenges them.

  • So the question isn't simply whether we can find a Bible verse that supports our position. With enough selective reading, people can find something that appears to support almost anything.

  • The real question is whether our interpretation survives when we keep reading.


  • The Bible Already Warned Us: Itching Ears and Willing Audiences

  • What we've just witnessed with Ahab isn't merely an unusual episode in Israel's history. The New Testament warns that the same pattern can develop among people who claim to follow Christ.

  • Consider Paul's instructions to Timothy in 2 Timothy 4:1–5. Paul charges Timothy to preach God's Word faithfully, whether the circumstances are favorable or unfavorable. He tells him to correct, rebuke, and encourage people through patient, careful teaching.

  • Notice that Paul includes all three responsibilities. There are times when people need encouragement. There are times when they need correction. And there are times when a preacher must confront something that Scripture identifies as wrong.

  • But then Paul issues a warning. A time will come when people will no longer tolerate sound teaching. Instead, they will gather teachers who tell them what their itching ears want to hear.

  • Does that sound familiar?

  • Ahab had four hundred prophets delivering the message he preferred. When someone finally spoke the truth, he didn't want to hear it.

  • Paul is warning Timothy that the same thing can happen in the church.

  • There's something particularly revealing in the Greek. Paul describes sound teaching as τῆς ὑγιαινούσης διδασκαλίας—healthy teaching. He says people will gather teachers κατὰ τὰς ἰδίας ἐπιθυμίας—according to their own desires. And then comes that memorable expression, κνηθόμενοι τὴν ἀκοήν, commonly translated as having itching ears.

  • The picture is of people seeking messages that satisfy their desires rather than teaching that promotes spiritual health.

  • And here's something we shouldn't overlook: Paul isn't describing only dishonest teachers deceiving innocent listeners. He's describing listeners actively selecting teachers who accommodate what they already want to believe.

  • False teaching can have a willing audience!

  • Think about how that changes the question. Before we ask why so many religious teachers tell people what they want to hear, perhaps we should ask why so many people want to hear it.

  • Ahab's prophets had an audience because Ahab wanted their message. The deception succeeded not simply because the prophets were persuasive, but because their message agreed with the king's desires.

  • And we can do exactly the same thing today. With thousands of sermons, podcasts, videos, and social-media teachers available at the touch of a button, we can keep searching until we find someone who tells us what we wanted to hear in the first place.

  • We can even convince ourselves that we're doing responsible biblical research because we've collected so many supporting opinions.

  • But a collection of agreeable teachers doesn't establish truth any more than Ahab's four hundred prophets did.

  • The real question is whether we're willing to listen when Scripture challenges our desires.

  • That's also why correction matters. Remember our discussion last week about having my sermons and interpretations challenged before I preach them? I don't want to be surrounded by voices that simply agree with me. I want mistakes exposed while there's still time to correct them. Scripture remains the authority, and anything we use to examine our reasoning must be evaluated against it.

  • Being corrected isn't failure. Refusing to be corrected can become dangerous.

  • And that raises another important question.


  • How Do We Identify False Teachers?

  • We've talked about the danger of choosing the wrong voices. But how do we actually recognize those voices?

  • And perhaps just as importantly, how do we avoid becoming Christians who accuse everyone who disagrees with us of being a false teacher?

  • Because that's another problem in modern Christianity. Apparently, all someone has to do is interpret a passage differently, and suddenly they're a heretic!

  • Disagreement doesn't automatically establish deception. Christians can disagree honestly about difficult passages. Teachers can misunderstand a text, make a mistake, or change their interpretation after further study. None of those things, by themselves, proves that someone is a destructive false teacher.

  • If we're going to make such a serious accusation, we'd better have something more substantial than the fact that we don't like what someone is saying.

  • Remember Ahab? He hated Micaiah because the prophet didn't tell him what he wanted to hear. We certainly don't want to adopt Ahab's standard for evaluating teachers!

  • Throughout this series, we've repeatedly encountered people who possessed extraordinary advantages but failed to remain faithful.

  • Solomon had extraordinary wisdom, yet his heart became divided. Jeroboam received a promise from God, yet he rearranged Israel's worship to protect his political kingdom. Ahab witnessed God's power and received repeated warnings, yet he preferred the messages that supported his desires.

  • Their stories remind us that knowledge, position, experience, popularity, and even religious activity cannot substitute for obedience.

  • So how do we evaluate someone who claims to teach God's Word?

  • Scripture directs our attention to the teaching itself, the person's character, their motives, and the fruit their ministry produces.

  • All of those things matter.

  • Examine the Teaching: Is It Faithful to Scripture?

  • We've already seen the importance of reading Scripture in context. A teacher can quote an actual Bible verse and still use it to support something the passage doesn't teach.

  • Satan demonstrated that when he quoted Psalm 91 to Jesus.

  • Therefore, our first responsibility is to examine whether the teaching agrees with Scripture when we read the passage carefully and consider the larger biblical context.

  • Does the interpretation account for what comes before and after the verse? Does it respect what the author is actually arguing? Does it agree with the broader teaching of Scripture, especially what Jesus and His apostles taught?

  • Or does the argument depend on isolating a convenient sentence while ignoring passages that challenge the conclusion?

  • A teaching doesn't become biblical simply because a Bible verse appears somewhere in the presentation.

  • But there's another test that we sometimes overlook.


  • Character Over Charisma: What Do Peter and Timothy Tell Us?

  • 2 Peter 2:1–3 gives us a particularly serious warning about false teachers.

  • Peter describes people who introduce destructive teaching, lead others into shameful conduct, and exploit believers through greed and deceptive words.

  • Notice that Peter doesn't limit the problem to incorrect theological statements. He also identifies the conduct and motives of the teachers themselves.

  • These are people who use religious influence to benefit themselves.

  • And Peter specifically connects their deception with money.

  • That's significant, especially when we consider how often Christianity is presented as a way to obtain wealth, influence, personal success, or a growing audience.

  • We should be asking whether a ministry is directing people toward Jesus Christ or making them increasingly dependent upon a particular religious personality.

  • Is the teacher serving the people, or are the people being used to serve the teacher?

  • Is the ministry characterized by generosity, service, integrity, and spiritual growth? Or do we see manipulation, personal enrichment, control, and endless self-promotion?

  • First Timothy 6 also warns about people who treat godliness as a means of financial gain. Paul doesn't condemn the legitimate support of those who minister. He condemns the corruption of godliness into a strategy for getting rich.

  • There's a tremendous difference between supporting ministry and exploiting people through ministry.

  • And sometimes the easiest way to exploit people is to keep telling them exactly what they want to hear.

  • If the congregation feels wonderful every Sunday, if everyone is constantly reassured that God approves of everything they're doing, and if nobody is ever challenged to repent or change, it's worth asking what that teaching is actually producing.

  • Are we encouraging people to grow in Christ?

  • Or are we keeping them comfortable so they'll keep coming back, keep applauding, and keep giving?

  • Now consider what Paul says about the qualifications for church leadership.

  • In 1 Timothy 3:2–7, he describes a leader whose life should be above reproach, someone faithful, self-controlled, wise, hospitable, respectable, and capable of teaching.

  • But notice what else appears on that list.

  • A church leader must not be violent or quarrelsome. He must be gentle, and he must not love money.

  • Think about those requirements for a moment.

  • Self-control. Gentleness. Not quarrelsome. Not loving money.

  • That might have just eliminated ninety percent of the preachers arguing on social media!

  • I'm exaggerating, of course, but you understand my point.

  • We sometimes evaluate religious teachers almost entirely by their ability to speak. Are they entertaining? Are they clever? Can they win an argument? Can they deliver an emotional sermon? Do they attract a crowd?

  • Yet the New Testament places extraordinary emphasis on their character.

  • Paul doesn't tell Timothy to find the most charismatic speaker in the room. He describes someone whose life demonstrates the qualities expected of a mature Christian.

  • Of course, the ability to teach matters. It's explicitly included among the qualifications. But being gifted doesn't excuse being ungodly.

  • And that brings us back to Zedekiah.

  • Remember him?

  • He had the iron horns. He had the confident message. He had hundreds of prophets supporting his prediction. He had the impressive religious presentation.

  • But what happened when Micaiah challenged him?

  • He walked up and slapped him in the face!

  • Think about that. Here's someone claiming to speak by the Spirit of the LORD, and when another prophet contradicts him, his response is physical aggression.

  • The presentation looked impressive. His response to correction revealed something about his character.

  • And that should make us think carefully about the teachers we follow.

  • Can they be questioned? Can they be corrected? Are they accountable to anyone? Do they demonstrate humility when confronted with a legitimate concern?

  • Or do they become angry, defensive, manipulative, or hostile whenever someone disagrees?

  • The New Testament doesn't ask us to ignore those questions simply because someone is talented or popular.

  • Jesus Said to Examine the Fruit

  • Jesus gives us another important standard in Matthew 7:15–20.

  • He warns that false prophets can appear harmless while being inwardly dangerous. Then He explains that we can recognize them by their fruit.

  • Notice that Jesus directs our attention beyond appearances.

  • And if we keep reading into verses 21–23, the warning becomes even more striking. Jesus describes people making remarkable religious claims, even appealing to impressive works performed in His name, yet those claims do not automatically establish that they belong to Him.

  • Religious activity is not the same thing as obedience.

  • That fits remarkably well with what we've witnessed in Ahab's court. Four hundred prophets were making confident religious declarations, but their impressive presentation didn't establish that their message was true.

  • Jesus tells us to examine the fruit.

  • Galatians 5 gives us a helpful picture of what that means. Paul contrasts the works of the flesh—including hostility, jealousy, outbursts of anger, selfish ambition, and division—with the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control.

  • So when we're evaluating a teacher, we should pay attention to more than the words coming from the pulpit.

  • Are we seeing the fruit of the Spirit?

  • Or are we seeing the works of the flesh dressed up in religious language?

  • Now, no Christian leader is perfect. We all have areas where we need correction and growth. But there's a difference between someone who acknowledges a failure and responds to correction, and someone who repeatedly justifies ungodly conduct by appealing to their spiritual authority.

  • We shouldn't confuse a teacher's gifts with the fruit of their life.

  • And we certainly shouldn't assume that impressive religious appearances establish spiritual authenticity.

  • Paul makes a related point in 2 Corinthians 11:13–15. He warns about false apostles disguising themselves as servants of Christ, and he reminds the Corinthians that even Satan can disguise himself as an angel of light.

  • That's a remarkable warning.

  • Deception doesn't always look obviously evil. Sometimes it looks holy, sounds spiritual, and claims to speak for God.

  • That's precisely why discernment requires more than an attractive presentation or a persuasive personality.


  • Test the Teacher: Signs, Results, and the Gospel

  • Here's another surprising biblical test.

  • In Deuteronomy 13:1–4, Moses describes a situation in which someone claims prophetic authority and predicts a sign or miracle.

  • And the sign actually happens!

  • We might expect the fulfilled prediction to settle the question. Surely a person who can accurately predict something extraordinary must be speaking for God.

  • But that's not what Moses says.

  • He explains that even when the predicted sign occurs, God's people must reject anyone who attempts to lead them away from the LORD toward other gods.

  • Think about the significance of that instruction.

  • Even a fulfilled prediction or impressive supernatural sign doesn't automatically establish that someone is speaking for God.

  • The message still matters.

  • Does the teaching lead people toward faithfulness to the true God, or away from Him?

  • This also connects with what we studied in James about divided loyalty. God doesn't call His people to demonstrate extraordinary religious experiences while maintaining divided allegiance. He calls us to faithful obedience.

  • And the New Testament continues that standard.

  • In Galatians 1:6–9, Paul expresses astonishment that believers are abandoning the gospel they received for a distorted message. He then makes an astonishing declaration: even if Paul himself—or an angel from heaven—were to proclaim a different gospel, that message must be rejected.

  • Did you catch that?

  • Even an angel!

  • Apparently, spectacular credentials don't give anyone permission to rewrite the gospel.

  • Paul doesn't tell the Galatians to accept a message because the messenger is impressive. He directs them back to the gospel that was preached and received.

  • And 1 John 4:1–3 likewise commands believers not to accept every claim of spiritual inspiration. John tells them to test the spirits because many false prophets have gone into the world. In that particular setting, a central test concerns whether the teacher acknowledges the truth that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh.

  • The point is that spiritual claims must be examined in relation to the truth about Jesus Christ.

  • Together, these passages give us a substantial biblical standard.

  • We test the teaching against Scripture. We examine the character and motives of the teacher. We consider what the ministry produces. And we measure its message against the gospel of Jesus Christ.

  • Not every disagreement makes someone a false teacher. But neither does an impressive ministry place someone beyond examination.

  • Remember Zedekiah's iron horns. Remember the four hundred unanimous prophets. Remember how confidently they spoke.


  • Don't let the production fool you.

  • And while we're testing teachers, let's not forget to examine why certain messages appeal to us.

  • Sometimes the question isn't merely whether a teacher is giving people what they want.

  • It's whether we're choosing that teacher precisely because they're giving us what we want.


  • The Feel-Good Show: Entertainment Over Conviction

  • Now let's bring this into the modern church, because I think this is where the application becomes especially uncomfortable.

  • We live in an age when churches can produce extraordinary presentations. We have excellent sound systems, beautiful lighting, talented musicians, professional video, impressive technology, and gifted communicators.

  • And let me be clear: none of those things is inherently wrong.

  • You know I enjoy humor. We use technology at C3. We put effort into communicating well, and I certainly don't think a sermon has to be boring to be biblical!

  • There's nothing spiritual about making people miserable because your presentation is terrible.

  • But there's a question we need to ask.

  • What are we actually trying to accomplish?

  • Are we helping people encounter God's Word and grow as disciples of Jesus Christ?

  • Or are we simply producing an enjoyable religious experience?

  • Because those aren't necessarily the same thing.

  • A church can have a packed auditorium, an extraordinary worship team, a charismatic preacher, a polished presentation, and a congregation that leaves feeling wonderful.

  • But what did the congregation actually receive?

  • Was Scripture faithfully taught?

  • Were people encouraged to examine their lives?

  • Was sin addressed when the biblical passage required it?

  • Were people equipped to grow in maturity and obedience?

  • Or did everyone simply enjoy the show?

  • Remember the scene in Ahab's court. Two kings dressed in royal robes. Hundreds of prophets. Dramatic visual aids. A confident, encouraging message.

  • What a service!

  • But that impressive production was delivering exactly what Ahab wanted to hear instead of what he needed to hear.

  • And that's what we must guard against.

  • The problem isn't the quality of the presentation. The problem is when the presentation becomes a substitute for the truth.


  • When Emotion Becomes Manipulation

  • There's another aspect of modern worship and preaching that deserves our attention: emotional manipulation.

  • Now, there's absolutely nothing wrong with emotion in church.

  • God created us as emotional beings! Music can move us. Scripture can bring us to tears. A sermon can challenge us deeply. Worship can be joyful, and sometimes repentance can be painful.

  • I don't believe genuine spirituality requires us to suppress emotion.

  • But there's an important difference between a genuine emotional response to God's Word and an emotional response that someone has deliberately manufactured to obtain a particular result.

  • Lighting, musical repetition, dramatic pauses, emotionally charged language, and carefully timed appeals can all influence the way people respond.

  • Again, those elements aren't automatically wrong.

  • The issue is how they're being used.

  • Are we using music and presentation to help people understand and respond thoughtfully to the truth?

  • Or are we using those elements to pressure people into decisions they haven't properly considered?

  • Sometimes a congregation can be emotionally worked up through an extended musical atmosphere, only to have that emotion immediately directed toward an offering, an altar call, or some other desired response.

  • At what point are we allowing the Holy Spirit to bring conviction through God's Word, and at what point are we attempting to engineer an outcome?

  • That's a question worth asking.

  • In 2 Corinthians 4:2, Paul rejects deceptive practices and the distortion of God's Word. In 1 Corinthians 2:4–5, he emphasizes that the Corinthians' faith should rest upon God's power rather than merely human persuasive ability.

  • Paul certainly knew how to reason, persuade, and communicate effectively. But his objective wasn't to manufacture a response through clever manipulation.

  • The objective was genuine faith grounded in the truth of God.

  • Genuine conviction responds to truth. Emotional manipulation attempts to manufacture a response.

  • And that distinction matters enormously.

  • A successful church service isn't necessarily one in which everyone cried, cheered, raised their hands, or walked forward.

  • The question is whether people heard God's Word and responded to it sincerely.

  • Sometimes that response will be joyful. Sometimes it will involve repentance. Sometimes it will require serious thought, prayer, and difficult decisions after the service has ended.

  • We shouldn't confuse an immediate emotional reaction with lasting spiritual transformation.


  • Scripture Was Given to Correct Us, Not Affirm Our Sin

  • This brings us to something Paul tells Timothy in 2 Timothy 3:16–17.

  • Remember, these words come immediately before the charge in chapter 4 to preach the Word faithfully and the warning about people gathering teachers who satisfy their itching ears.

  • Paul explains that all Scripture is inspired by God and useful for teaching us what is true, exposing what is wrong in our lives, correcting us, and training us in righteousness. God uses Scripture to prepare and equip His people for every good work.

  • Now, stop and consider what Paul just described.

  • What is Scripture supposed to accomplish?

  • It teaches us the truth. It exposes wrongdoing. It corrects us when we're wrong. It trains us to live righteously.

  • God didn't give us His Word simply to make us feel good, affirm our choices, or justify our sin. He gave it to transform us!

  • That doesn't mean Scripture never encourages us. Of course it does! The Bible is filled with extraordinary promises, comfort, hope, and assurance.

  • But biblical encouragement is not the same thing as telling people that everything they're doing is fine when Scripture says otherwise.

  • Sometimes the most loving thing a pastor can do is encourage someone who is struggling.

  • And sometimes the most loving thing a pastor can do is tell someone that what they're doing needs to change.

  • Paul tells Timothy to correct, rebuke, and encourage—with patient teaching.

  • All three are part of faithful ministry.

  • A church that only rebukes and condemns people is missing something important.

  • But a church that only entertains and reassures people, never confronting what Scripture confronts, is missing something equally important.

  • The objective isn't to make everyone comfortable, and it certainly isn't to make everyone miserable.

  • The objective is to help people become more like Jesus Christ.

  • And that's exactly what Paul explains in another passage we've discussed before.


  • Ephesians 4: The Goal Is Spiritual Maturity

  • In Ephesians 4:11–16, Paul explains that Christ gives ministry gifts to His church for the purpose of equipping God's people for works of service and building up the body of Christ.

  • The goal is unity in the faith, knowledge of the Son of God, and spiritual maturity.

  • That's the purpose of Christian ministry!

  • Not simply attracting an audience.

  • Not merely creating an emotional experience.

  • Not maintaining a religious organization by keeping everyone happy.

  • Equipping believers. Building up the church. Developing maturity in Christ.

  • Paul even explains that mature believers should no longer be tossed around by every new teaching or carried away by deceptive influences. Instead, speaking the truth in love, the church grows into Christ, who is its head.

  • Think about how perfectly that fits the account of Ahab.

  • Ahab had hundreds of prophets, but their message didn't lead him toward truth. It reinforced his desires and encouraged him toward destruction.

  • He didn't need another impressive religious presentation.

  • He needed to listen to what God was actually saying.

  • And the same principle applies to us.

  • A church can be entertaining without being shallow. A preacher can be humorous without compromising Scripture. An excellent worship service can be genuinely edifying.

  • But an impressive presentation doesn't excuse teaching that consistently avoids the truth.

  • Neither does making people uncomfortable automatically prove a sermon was faithful to Scripture. A preacher can be harsh, obnoxious, and completely wrong!

  • The standard isn't entertainment versus boredom. It isn't comfort versus discomfort.

  • The standard is faithfulness to God's Word and the spiritual fruit that teaching produces.

  • Are people learning to understand Scripture? Are they growing in Christlike character? Are they being equipped to serve? Are they learning to recognize truth, exercise discernment, and respond to correction?

  • Or are they becoming increasingly dependent upon a particular personality, production, or religious experience?

  • That's the difference between building an audience and making disciples.

  • And it brings us back to the central question we've been asking throughout this sermon.

  • Ahab didn't simply find himself surrounded by false prophets. He preferred their message because it affirmed what he already wanted.

  • So we need to examine more than the teachers we listen to.

  • Don't just test the teacher. Test why you want to believe the teacher.

  • Because ultimately, the issue isn't how many people agree with us, how impressive the presentation may be, or how good the message makes us feel.

  • The issue is whether we're willing to hear and obey the truth—even when it challenges us.


  • How Do We Stop Looking for Confirmation?

  • Surrender Before Searching: The Necessity of Humility

  • So how do we stop looking for confirmation? We've spent considerable time examining the dangers of confirmation bias, the ways Scripture can be manipulated, and the responsibility we have to examine both our teachers and our own motivations. But let's make this practical. How do we actually guard ourselves against the tendency to search for whatever supports what we already believe?

  • The first step is to surrender before searching. Before studying a difficult theological question or seeking spiritual advice, we need to ask ourselves whether we're genuinely willing to change our minds. If Scripture challenges something we believe, something we desire, or a decision we've already made, are we actually prepared to respond?

  • I've had people come to me over the years and make statements that I find absolutely astonishing. They'll be discussing a theological position or something they believe, and they'll announce, "This is something I'm never going to change my mind about."

  • Think about what an extraordinary statement that is! My response is usually to ask them a very simple question: "You mean to tell me that if I open the Bible and show you Scriptures that clearly demonstrate the opposite of what you believe, you're still not going to change your mind?"

  • And I've actually had people respond, quite seriously, "No. I'm not going to change my mind."

  • That's frightening!

  • My friends, that person is lost. They've reached a place where their commitment to an existing belief has become more important than their willingness to hear the truth. And my response is always the same: That's not humility. We cannot have a meaningful conversation about Scripture if someone has already decided that no amount of biblical evidence could possibly change their position.

  • Now, this doesn't mean we should abandon our convictions every time someone challenges us. There are good reasons to hold firmly to beliefs that are well established in Scripture. But there's an enormous difference between holding a conviction because we've examined the evidence and refusing to consider evidence because we've already decided that our conviction cannot be questioned.

  • Humility requires the willingness to be corrected. It means recognizing that our understanding isn't infallible and that we may still have something to learn. We should approach Scripture with confidence in God's Word, not unquestioning confidence in our own interpretations of it.

  • So don't begin by asking God to bless your answer. Begin by being willing to hear His.

  • And that requires humility.


  • Keep Reading: Let Scripture Establish Its Own Context

  • The next step is something we've discussed repeatedly, and by now it should be familiar: Keep reading!

  • When we're examining a difficult passage, we need to read the verse before it and the verse after it. We need to read the entire paragraph, and often the entire chapter. We should understand who's speaking, who's being addressed, what circumstances are involved, and what the biblical author is actually arguing.

  • Context matters. Does our interpretation agree with the broader teaching of Scripture? Are we allowing the passage to communicate what its author intended, or are we extracting a convenient statement and assigning it a meaning that serves our own purposes?

  • We've already seen how that problem develops. Someone takes a verse from Malachi and turns it into a formula for financial prosperity. Satan quotes Psalm 91 in an attempt to persuade Jesus to test God. In both cases, the larger context and the broader teaching of Scripture are essential for evaluating the application.

  • We shouldn't build our theology around a screenshot, a social-media post, or a convenient sentence detached from its context. Just because someone places a Bible reference beneath a statement doesn't mean the statement accurately represents what Scripture teaches.

  • One of the best examples of responsible biblical examination appears in Acts 17, where we encounter the believers in Berea.

  • Paul had been preaching in Thessalonica, where he reasoned from the Scriptures over three Sabbath days. Eventually, opposition forced him and Silas to leave, and they traveled to Berea. There, the people received Paul's message eagerly, but they didn't simply accept everything he said without examination.

  • Acts 17:11 tells us that the Bereans searched the Scriptures day after day to determine whether Paul and Silas were teaching the truth.

  • Think about that! They're listening to the apostle Paul, yet they're still examining the Scriptures to evaluate what he's saying. And rather than criticizing them for questioning an apostle, the biblical account commends them for their approach.

  • That's the attitude we should have toward biblical teaching. We can listen eagerly, remain open to learning, and appreciate the people who teach us while still examining what they say against Scripture.

  • The authority ultimately belongs to God's Word, not to the personality or reputation of the person explaining it.


  • Test Spiritual Claims: Not Every Message Comes From God

  • Closely connected to examining Scripture is the responsibility to test spiritual claims.

  • In 1 Thessalonians 5:19–22, Paul writes:

  • "Do not stifle the Holy Spirit. Do not scoff at prophecies, but test everything that is said. Hold on to what is good. Stay away from every kind of evil."

  • Notice the balance in Paul's instructions. He doesn't tell believers to reject every claim of spiritual activity or dismiss every prophetic message. He specifically warns against despising such messages. But neither does he tell Christians to accept everything simply because someone claims to be speaking by the Spirit.

  • Instead, he tells them to test what is said and hold on to what is good.

  • That's why we take discernment seriously when someone believes they have a prophetic word. We don't automatically assume the person is dishonest or that the claim should be rejected without consideration. But neither do we treat the statement as authoritative simply because someone introduces it with the words, "God told me."

  • A spiritual-sounding claim doesn't automatically become a message from God because the person delivering it is sincere, confident, emotional, or persuasive.

  • We test it against the Word of God.

  • And that takes us directly back to Ahab and Micaiah. Ahab had approximately four hundred prophets confidently claiming that victory was assured. At least one of them explicitly invoked the LORD. But their religious language and confident predictions didn't establish that they were delivering God's message.

  • The same standard applies today. We must be willing to examine spiritual claims carefully, holding on to what is good and rejecting what contradicts the truth revealed in Scripture.


  • Invite Correction: Find People Who Will Challenge You

  • Another practical safeguard against confirmation bias is to deliberately invite correction.

  • Find mature Christians who are willing to challenge your thinking rather than simply agree with everything you say. Surround yourself with people who take Scripture seriously, who can explain why they believe what they believe, and who aren't afraid to tell you when they think you've made a mistake.

  • One particularly useful exercise is to ask someone to show you the strongest biblical argument against your current interpretation. Don't simply ask them to repeat the arguments you've already heard and dismissed. Ask them to explain the opposing position as carefully and faithfully as they can.

  • Then examine it.

  • And we need to apply that standard to everyone, including our favorite teachers and our pastors. Nobody should be placed in a position where their interpretation becomes immune to examination simply because we respect them, appreciate their teaching, or agree with most of what they say.

  • That's part of why I explained earlier that I want my own sermon preparation challenged. I want historical mistakes identified, biblical arguments examined, and interpretations questioned when there's reason to question them. I'd rather discover that I've made a mistake before I preach than confidently teach something that isn't true.

  • But the same principle must apply to us as listeners. If someone presents a sound biblical argument demonstrating that we've misunderstood something, we should be willing to change our position.

  • That isn't weakness. It isn't a failure of faith. It's evidence that we value the truth more than our own need to be right.


  • Respond to the Truth: Don't Keep Shopping for Another Answer

  • Finally, when Scripture reveals something in our lives that needs to change, we need to respond.

  • This is where everything we've discussed becomes personal. It's possible to study a passage carefully, recognize what it teaches, and even acknowledge that our previous understanding was mistaken, yet still refuse to do anything about it.

  • But the purpose of biblical instruction isn't merely to accumulate information. God's Word is intended to shape the way we believe, think, and live.

  • So when Scripture challenges us, we shouldn't keep shopping for a different interpretation until we find someone who gives us permission to ignore what we've discovered. We shouldn't immediately search for another teacher, another video, or another commentary that will restore our confidence in the position we preferred.

  • Remember the motivations that often lie behind confirmation bias: comfort, identity, and control.

  • Sometimes we resist the truth because accepting it would require us to change something. Perhaps we've invested years defending a particular belief. Maybe our position has become part of our identity, or perhaps acknowledging the truth would require us to reconsider a relationship, a decision, a habit, or a lifestyle we've become comfortable with.

  • Changing our minds can cost us something. Admitting that we were wrong can be uncomfortable, particularly when we've publicly defended a position or organized important parts of our lives around it.

  • But that discomfort doesn't make the truth any less important.

  • Ahab repeatedly encountered opportunities to listen to God, yet he continued choosing the messages that supported what he wanted. Even after the deception was revealed to him, he proceeded with his plans. His commitment to the outcome he desired proved stronger than his willingness to respond to the warning he'd received.

  • We don't have to repeat his mistake.

  • We can approach Scripture with humility, keep reading until we understand the context, test spiritual claims, invite correction, and respond when God's Word challenges us.

  • Because ultimately, the temporary comfort of believing a lie cannot provide the freedom that comes from living in the truth.


  • The Good Shepherd and the Voice of Truth

  • From a Failed Shepherd to the Good Shepherd

  • As we come to the conclusion of this message, let's return to something Micaiah said in 1 Kings 22. When he delivered God's warning to Ahab, he described seeing Israel scattered across the mountains like sheep without a shepherd. It was a picture of a nation about to lose its king, but it also reminds us of the tremendous responsibility entrusted to those who lead God's people.

  • Ahab was supposed to be a shepherd to Israel. As king, he had a responsibility to lead the people according to God's instructions, protecting them and directing them toward faithfulness to the LORD. But throughout his reign, we repeatedly witnessed something very different. Ahab was more concerned with protecting his own plans, securing his own desires, and surrounding himself with people who would tell him what he wanted to hear.

  • And when God sent him a warning, Ahab refused to listen. Rather than changing course, he continued toward a battle that would ultimately cost him his life. His refusal to receive the truth didn't affect him alone. It placed the people he was supposed to lead in danger as well.

  • Now consider the contrast with Jesus.

  • In John 10, Jesus describes Himself as the Good Shepherd who gives His life for the sheep. That's an extraordinary contrast to what we've just witnessed in the life of Ahab. Ahab was willing to lead his people into disaster because he refused God's warning. Jesus, on the other hand, willingly gives Himself for His people.

  • Ahab was concerned with preserving his own interests, while Jesus demonstrates the very nature of sacrificial love. Where Ahab failed in his responsibility as a shepherd, Jesus reveals what the Good Shepherd truly is. He doesn't exploit the sheep for His own benefit. He loves them, protects them, and ultimately lays down His life for them.

  • And that brings us to another important statement Jesus makes about the truth.


  • Those Who Belong to the Truth Listen to His Voice

  • Remember what Jesus tells Pontius Pilate in John 18. Standing before the Roman governor, Jesus explains that He came into the world to testify to the truth, and that those who belong to the truth listen to His voice.

  • Think about that statement in light of everything we've studied today. We've encountered a king who had access to hundreds of prophets, yet rejected the one delivering God's warning. We've seen how religious language can be manipulated, how people can select the teachers who support their desires, and even how Scripture itself can be quoted in ways that distort its meaning.

  • But Jesus calls His followers to something entirely different. He calls us to listen to His voice, to receive the truth, and to follow Him.

  • That's where I want to leave us this morning. The question isn't whether we can find someone to tell us what we want to hear. The question is whether we actually want to hear the truth.

  • And that question is just as relevant to us today as it was to Ahab thousands of years ago. We have access to more biblical resources, teachers, sermons, commentaries, and theological discussions than perhaps any generation in Christian history. We can find someone willing to support almost any position we want to defend. But having access to an enormous number of religious voices doesn't necessarily mean we're listening to the voice of truth.

  • The challenge is whether we're willing to examine what we hear, test it against Scripture, and respond when God's Word challenges something we believe.


  • Correction Is an Opportunity to Grow

  • Now, you came back after last week's challenging message, and apparently, you really can take a beating! After everything we discussed about church attendance, spiritual discipline, and commitment, here you are again. And today we've spent another morning examining some pretty uncomfortable questions about our beliefs, our motivations, and the people we choose to listen to.

  • But the question isn't whether we can take another hard sermon. The question is whether we're willing to let God's Word correct us.

  • And I want to make something very clear as we finish. When Scripture exposes something in our lives, that's not an invitation to despair. It's an opportunity to repent, change direction, and grow. Correction isn't supposed to leave us feeling hopeless. It's meant to bring us back into alignment with the truth.

  • We don't have to respond to correction the way Ahab did. We don't have to become defensive, reject the messenger, or keep searching for someone who will give us a more comfortable answer. We can humble ourselves, examine what Scripture says, acknowledge where we've been wrong, and make the changes we need to make.

  • Remember that Ahab heard the truth and refused it. He was warned about the deception surrounding him, yet he still chose to follow the voices promising the outcome he wanted.

  • We don't have to repeat his decision.

  • Jesus isn't calling us to become people who never need correction. He's calling His sheep to hear His voice and follow Him. That means remaining humble enough to learn, willing enough to change, and faithful enough to follow the truth even when it challenges our preferences.

  • Because ultimately, our confidence doesn't rest in our ability to get every theological question right, or in finding teachers who always agree with us. Our confidence rests in Jesus Christ Himself.

  • As Jesus declares in John 14:6, He is the way, the truth, and the life.

  • And if we genuinely want to follow Him, then we must be willing to hear the truth—not merely what we want to hear.

  • ________________________________________
  • ©️Copyright 2026 Gene Simco Most Scripture quotations are taken from the Holy Bible, New Living Translation, copyright ©1996, 2004, 2015 by Tyndale House Foundation. Used by permission of Tyndale House Publishers, Carol Stream, Illinois 60188. All rights reserved. Scriptures in brackets reflect the original Biblical languages.
Contact
(239) 597-1000
info@c3naples.org
Address
1048 Castello Drive,Naples, FL 34103, USA
Copyright 2026© All rights reserved.

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website, and analyze website traffic. By clicking Accept you consent to our use of cookies. Cookies and Privacy Policy.

Your Cookie Settings

We use cookies to enable essential functionality on our website and analyze website traffic. For more information, read our Cookies and Privacy Policy below.

Cookie Categories
Essential

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our websites.

Analytics

These cookies collect information that is used in aggregate and in an anonymized form to help us understand how our website is being used and how effectively our site is performing.